Global Sources
EE Times-Asia
Stay in touch with EE Times Asia
EE Times-Asia > Memory/Storage

Toshiba wins NAND suit versus Hynix, says report

Posted: 28 Mar 2006 ?? ?Print Version ?Bookmark and Share

Keywords:Peter Clarke? Hynix Semiconductor? Toshiba? NAND flash memory?

Hynix Semiconductor Inc. was ordered by a Japanese court on March 24 to stop selling NAND flash memory components in Japan in relation to a lawsuit brought by Toshiba Corp., according to a Reuters report that quoted Toshiba as its source.

The company said it would appeal and that the ruling would only affect some of its NAND flash memory products. Hynix was also ordered to pay Toshiba about $66,000 in damages, the report said.

Toshiba filed the suit against Hynix in the Tokyo District Court in November 2004 for what it said was the infringement of patents on NAND-type flash memory chips.

Toshiba and Hynix entered into a patent cross-licensing agreement in August 1996 that included semiconductor products. The companies started negotiating an extension of the agreement prior to its Dec. 31, 2002 expiration, but failed to agree what would be reasonable fees for access to Toshiba patents.

Hynix collaborates with STMicroelectronics (ST) on the development and production of flash memory chips but Toshiba did not list ST in its lawsuit filed in 2004. At the same time Toshiba filed a similar suit in the United States against Hynix and its U.S. subsidiaries for infringement of Toshiba's DRAM and NAND flash memory patents.

Hynix received another setback earlier in 2006 when the Japan imposed a 27.2 percent duty on DRAM imports from the South Korean chip maker. The decision was arrived at after DRAM makers Elpida Memory Inc and Micron Japan Ltd., argued that Hynix had received what amounted to state subsidy in the form of banks agreeing to convert massive debts into equity positions.

- Peter Clarke
EE Times

Article Comments - Toshiba wins NAND suit versus Hynix,...
*? You can enter [0] more charecters.
*Verify code:


Visit Asia Webinars to learn about the latest in technology and get practical design tips.

Back to Top