Global Sources
EE Times-Asia
Stay in touch with EE Times Asia
EE Times-Asia > Manufacturing/Packaging

Study: Laser printers emit hazardous particles

Posted: 07 Aug 2007 ?? ?Print Version ?Bookmark and Share

Keywords:health hazards? laser printers? particles?

According to a study released last week, some laser printers used in home and office environments pollute the air with potentially hazardous toner particles.

The study classified 17 out of 62 printers as "high particle emitters" because they released so much toner powder into the air. One of the printers released ultrafine toner particles at a rate comparable with cigarette smoking, according to the American Chemical Society.

Not all printers deserve warning labels, however. Thirty-seven of the 62 printers tested did not release enough particles to reduce air quality. Six released low levels of particles and two released medium levels.

Australian proponents
The study included Canon, Hewlett-Packard, Ricoh and Toshiba printers sold in Australia and the United States. It was conducted by Lidia Morawska, a professor at Queensland University of Technology in Brisbane, Australia, and colleagues, with funding from Queensland Department of Public Works and The Cooperative Research Centre for Construction Innovation.

"The highest printer particle number emission rate found in the chamber study was 1.6 * 1011 particle min-1, which is close to the median value of submicrometer particle number emission rates for activities, such as cigarette smoking (1.91 * 1011 particle min-1), occurring in residential houses," the study said. The high emitter list includes one Toshiba model and the rest of the listed printers are manufactured by HP.

The study notes that printer emissions are highly variable and that some printers, such as the HP LaserJet 5, can be either non-emitters or high emitters of particles in different circumstances. "The high standard deviation of the average emission rates estimated in this study also indicates that the particle emission process and the behavior of individual printers are complex and that they are still far from being completely understood," the study said. "Many factors, such as printer model, printer age, cartridge model and cartridge age may affect the particle emission process and all of these factors require further study."

Chance discovery
Morawska said that her group discovered printer pollution by chance. "It wasn't an area that we consciously decided to study," Morawska told the American Chemical Society news service. "We came across it by chance. Initially we were studying the efficiency of ventilation systems to protect office settings from outdoor air pollutants. We soon realized that we were seeing air pollution originating indoors, from laser printers."

Morawska and her associates found that indoor particle levels increased by a factor of five during work hours, when printers are used. New toner cartridges and graphics-intensive print jobs added to the amount of toner particles in the air.

The inhalation of ultrafine particles can affect human health in different ways, depending on the material inhaled and the quantity. But such particles can cause respiratory irritation or more serve conditions including cardiovascular problems or cancer. According to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, "Small particles less than 10?m in diameter pose the greatest problems, because they can get deep into your lungs, and some may even get into your bloodstream."

Current toner particles typically range from 8?m to 10?m, according to Wikipedia.

The toner particles measured in the study ranged from 15nm to 710nm, or 0.015?m to 0.71?m.

HP responds
Meanwhile, the day after the study was released, HP issued a statement belying its results. The company said "testing of ultrafine particles is a very new scientific discipline" and there are no indications that emissions of these particles from laser printers "are associated with special health risks."

HP said it has been working with two leading authorities on the subject: the Air Quality Sciences in the United States and the Wilhelm-Klauditz Institute in Germany. The company's design criteria for its laser prints also incorporate guidelines from the Blue Angel program in Germany and the Greenguard program in the United States, according to the statement.

"HP hopes to learn more from the study authors about how products were chosen for the study, how ranges were determined given no standards exist, and many other factors that could have influenced the results," the statement said.

HP's Material Safety Data Sheet for its Color LaserJet 8500 Series suggests the risk from toner inhalation (for this particular model at least) is not particularly significant. "Minimal respiratory tract irritation may occur with exposure to large amounts of toner dust," the document states.

- Thomas Claburn

With additional reporting from EE Times-Asia

Article Comments - Study: Laser printers emit hazardous...
*? You can enter [0] more charecters.
*Verify code:


Visit Asia Webinars to learn about the latest in technology and get practical design tips.

Back to Top