Global Sources
EE Times-Asia
Stay in touch with EE Times Asia
EE Times-Asia > Controls/MCUs

Opinion: Tech longs for R&D backing, not simply cash

Posted: 30 Oct 2008 ?? ?Print Version ?Bookmark and Share

Keywords:R&D? automotive? government support?

The U.S. government cannot stop America's auto market from imploding. Neither can it save the equity market simply by pouring money into it.

Uncle Sam has a huge desire to help, but rescuing Detroit and Wall Street is beyond even its obviously enormous financial capacity. What the equity market and the automotive industry need even more than cold cash is assurance that things will improve. The only move that can set the auto industry and the economy straight is solid product innovation.

Need for R&D funding
There's a lesson to note for high-tech companies. As the U.S. government ponders offering General Motors Corp. financial assistance to hasten its takeover of Chrysler LLC, some in the high-tech industry wonder whether IC vendors should similarly call on politicians to assist the market with a cash infusion.

But like a few banks that weren't run into the ground, technology firms don't need a cash handout. What the industry needs is federal support for basic R&D, and for the government to foster an innovative environment that would be beneficial not for the industry, but also the rest of the global economy.

R&D feeds future growth, and it's something technology companies have always been good at. With some backing from the government in areas where the return on investment is longer than expected or product development is so extended and loaded with uncertainty that deeper pockets are essential.

That process is now in jeopardy on two fronts as the market value of technology companies plummet and the U.S. government, the primary facilitator of some of the industry's most important inventions like the Internet, continues its excessive deficit spending. This public debt will invariably result in cuts to discretionary spending, like R&D assistance to high-tech companies.

Even if the U.S. government wants to help the IC industry develop next-generation products or improve its process technology, for instance, it may not be able to do this because a huge chunk of available resources is being used up by the financial sector.

This occurs as technology firms are being forced to reduce operating costs, including R&D expenses, because of weakening demand and the need to conserve cash for all, but the most essential functions.

Downward global trends
Falling market valuation for technology companies is expected to worsen the situation.

High-tech companies have commonly relied on such mechanisms as stock options, share sales and initial public offerings to fund innovation, attract and compensate experienced staff, fund acquisitions and increase capital for expansion activities.

We will be experiencing a dramatic slowdown in such activities. EE Times recently analyzed the stock prices of eight leading technology firms and found the group's market value slid to a whopping $724 billion just last year, more or less equal to the amount Congress has spent on restoring liquidity to the banking sector.

Among the companies reviewed were Apple Inc., Cisco Systems Inc., Google, IBM Corp., Intel Corp., Microsoft Corp., Hewlett Packard and Yahoo, which are in the top list of key technology innovators, and their respective activities fuelled the development of new products that have helped boost global economic productivity.

Seeking gov't intervention
While all of these companies boast considerable cash reserves, it is obvious that the sharp decline in their market values will negatively affect their ability to continue funding future product development without some assistance from the government. The same applies to smaller companies, especially start-ups that have seen their access to seed and operating capital restricted by the tight credit market.

It would therefore seem rational that technology firms to seek Congress for help. After all, the U.S. government should not rescue one economic offspring and let the other suffer?

However, the industry must not rest its case for governmental assistance on a dubious argument for equitable treatment. It can hardly be truthfully said the high-tech market is facing a systemic problem that is in any way comparable to the structural crisis confronting financial companies, automakers and the real estate market.

Less demand from consumers
High-tech is being hurt like the rest of the economy, but its problems are related more to weakness in consumer and corporate demand than a bad bout of financial mismanagement, imbalanced portfolio or restrictions on operating funds.

Many tech companies have enough cash to trundle along without a government handout. When the industry was in bad shape at the start of the decade, company officials swiftly shuttered unprofitable plants and divisions, shifted operations across the globe and implemented various cost-cutting and productivity-boosting measures.

Ensuring the general economy can continue to benefit from the high-tech sector's ability to introduce productivity enhancement, any new economic incentive package must include funds for extensive R&D activities. Such move will promote innovation and foster the release of new high-tech products, enhance manufacturing efficiency and propel markets on a more solid footing in the years to come.

Government agencies like the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency can, as they have in the past, help lead the way. We were pleased to see that the agency has awarded a contract for industry research on next-generation MRAM technology. That's a good start.

Certainly, the benefits won't be immediate. On a long-term basis, however, funding basic technology R&D and fostering an environment for product innovation and process enhancements will lead to a more lasting boost to the economy than a direct cash injection.

- Bolaji Ojo
EE Times

Article Comments - Opinion: Tech longs for R&D backing,...
*? You can enter [0] more charecters.
*Verify code:


Visit Asia Webinars to learn about the latest in technology and get practical design tips.

Back to Top