Global Sources
EE Times-Asia
Stay in touch with EE Times Asia
EE Times-Asia > Manufacturing/Packaging

Android may face darker days ahead in wake of Apple's win

Posted: 29 Aug 2012 ?? ?Print Version ?Bookmark and Share

Keywords:Android? Tablets? Smartphone? iPhone? iPad?

In wake of Apple's victory in its patent suit against Samsung in San Jose's federal court, the Android community may be facing darker days. Apple now wields an arsenal of proven arguments which it can use against Android competitors in and out of court on the industrial design of its iPhone and the user interface of both the iPhone and iPad.

In terms of market share, Android handsets currently have a significant lead over the iPhone, thanks to the success of HTC, Motorola, Samsung and others. Some experts also believe that Android-based tablets from Amazon, Google, Samsung and others have the potential to leave the iPad in the dust.

However, the court decision has the potential to change the current market landscape.

Judge and Jury backs Apple's case
The San Jose jury decided most of the Samsung smartphones in the case infringe three design patents on the iPhone's industrial design and app screen (D 593,087; D 618, 677 and D 604,305). It also said most of the accused Samsung smartphones and some of its tablets infringe three Apple utility patents (US 7,469,381; US 7,864,163 and US 7,844,915) on the look-and-feel of the software on both the iPhone and iPad.

In addition, the jury said those patents were valid despite Samsung's attacks using world-class experts showing multiple examples of what it claimed were prior art. The jury also upheld Apple's claims Samsung handsets violated its registered and unregistered trade dress on the original and 3GS iPhones.

The San Jose jury weakened just one small but significant part of Apple's case. It said Samsung did not infringe Apple's design patent on the iPad (D 504,889), suggesting that patent was valid but relatively weak. It also said Apple did not prove its unregistered trade dress on the iPad was protectable.

The net result is Apple now has three proven user interface patents that can attack any Android smartphone or tablet in court or in private negotiations and three strong design patents useful against any iPhone look alike.

"This is a boost for Apple's patent enforcement efforts against Android worldwide," said Florian Mueller, an expert following the mobile patent wars.

"The rest of the Android ecosystem has just as much of a reason to be concerned about this as Samsung," Mueller said. "The immediate impact will be limited to Samsung, but Apple has proven its ability to enforce not only its design patents but also its multitouch software patents in federal court," he said.

"The verdict also lends credibility to Steve Jobs's characterization of Android as a 'stolen product,'" he added.

The San Jose decision also is likely to embolden Tim Cook to continue Jobs' vow to "go thermonuclear" in a patent war against Android backers.

1???2?Next Page?Last Page

Article Comments - Android may face darker days ahead i...
*? You can enter [0] more charecters.
*Verify code:


Visit Asia Webinars to learn about the latest in technology and get practical design tips.

Back to Top