Global Sources
EE Times-Asia
Stay in touch with EE Times Asia
EE Times-Asia > RF/Microwave

Jury gave fair verdict in Apple vs. Samsung case, foreman says

Posted: 30 Aug 2012 ?? ?Print Version ?Bookmark and Share

Keywords:Apple? Samsung? patent suit? trade dress?

"When it came time to do the [damages] calculations we had four people in the room with calculators. I looked over the shoulder of everyone working on calculators. We read all the numbers twice and double checked the figures again," he recalled.

"The only errors were two points of inconsistency which translated into four items about two tablets. There were a number of entries [on each table in the verdict form], and it was easy to transcribe wrongly," he said.

"We felt we were methodical, meticulous and fair," he added.

Highlight of a 40+ EE year career
After serving in the Navy, Hogan started his career in 1969 as a hard disk technician, spending three years in night school earning his EE degree. He worked for many of the top storage and computing companies including Memorex, Storage Technology, Digital Equipment, Seagate. Micropolis and Quantum. It was a time when drives were evolving from "the size of top-loading washing machines to bricks."

"Besides my family, this case was a highlight of my life-it's a landmark and precedent setting. It's a historic case. We've never had a patent infringement case this size or this kind of technology," he said.

When it was all over, "I didn't know I was going to be bombarded, but since the trial stopped both of my phones haven't stopped ringing," Hogan said.

His hour-long interview with EE Times took place after he had spent the day driving up to San Francisco and back for a live video interview with Bloomberg. Since the case was over, Hogan read much of the reporting on it and felt much of it was inaccurate.

"I determined I wanted to set the record straight," he said.

Jurors "had the ability to understand legal jargon, profit-and-loss statements, patent language and how hardware and software function-so we had the ability to come to a just decision and we stand by it," he said.

As a tech consumer, Hogan is a PC guy and owns a Motorola Droid smartphone. "People called me an Apple skeptic," he said.

"I never owned Apple products. I grew up in the computer industry on the hard drive side. What made me a PC person was my experience designing test equipment. Apple products are consumer oriented, and could not be easily used in test equipmen-they are not designed in that way," he said.

- Rick Merritt
??EE Times

?First Page?Previous Page 1???2???3

Article Comments - Jury gave fair verdict in Apple vs. ...
*? You can enter [0] more charecters.
*Verify code:


Visit Asia Webinars to learn about the latest in technology and get practical design tips.

Back to Top