Global Sources
EE Times-Asia
Stay in touch with EE Times Asia
EE Times-Asia > Power/Alternative Energy
Power/Alternative Energy??

Power tip: Benefits of synchronising power supplies

Posted: 03 Sep 2014 ?? ?Print Version ?Bookmark and Share

Keywords:power supply? electromagnetic interference? EMI? P-SPICE? asynchronous operation?

In the past several years, power systems have become complicated due to the requirement for multiple power supply rails. To meet these requirements, multiple switching supplies are often employed. One key decision to be made is whether to synchronize switching frequencies or to let each power supply switch independently. Not synchronizing results in less circuitry, while synchronizing may help to reduce filtering costs and lower electromagnetic interference (EMI).

To illustrate the impact of asynchronous operation, the circuit of figure 1 was simulated with P-SPICE. The current sources represent the input currents to the supplies. Figure 1 shows the waveforms of the two power supply currents and the ripple voltage on the capacitor.

Figure 1: Beating effect on two asynchronous power supplies increases input ripple voltage.

Ripple voltage is at a minimum when the two converters are out of phase, and it is at maximum when they are in phase. In this case, there is almost a 2-to-1 difference in output ripple voltage. This is one of the strong arguments for synchronizing power supplies. You can reduce input voltage ripple by judiciously selecting the phasing of the various supplies. The second benefit is that the ripple current also can be reduced. In this case, when the supplies are out of phase with a 0.25 duty factor (DF) on each phase, the effective DF is 0.5, so the ripple current is:

Figure 2: This FFT of input voltage simulation showsno sum and difference components.

The current sources were operating at 180 kHz and 200 kHz, and there are only fundamentals and harmonics of those switching frequencies. To generate sum and difference products, a multiplication is required, which is usually done with a nonlinear device like a switching diode or transistor (remember sin(u)sin(v)=1/2(cos(u-v)-cos(u+v))?).

However, if you examine the average voltage from which the power supply draws power during each cycle in figure 1, you will find that it has a variation related to the difference frequency. It is then this frequency that can make its way to the output of the power supply through poor audio rejection in the power supply. This can be caused by ineffective voltage feedforward, hysteretic control, or ineffective current-mode control, and it is usually a second-order effect.

Another way this beating phenomenon can make it to the output of a power system is through a poorly designed grounding system. Ground current flow can create voltages much like figure 2 in adjacent switchers. As an example, we had a power system that exhibited this. To prove the point, we conducted an experiment. We increased the bulk input capacitor and found we had no impact. Then we added small inductors in the power feeds to the switchers. We found that we minimized the interaction by keeping another power supply's ripple current out of the ground of the victim supply.

1???2?Next Page?Last Page

Article Comments - Power tip: Benefits of synchronising...
*? You can enter [0] more charecters.
*Verify code:


Visit Asia Webinars to learn about the latest in technology and get practical design tips.

Back to Top